WHEN PARENTS SPLIT, DO SIBLINGS SPLIT TOO?

Beyond Divorce – Preserving the Sibling Bond

It’s not unusual in mediation for one spouse to be eager to finalize the divorce while the other drags their feet. Often, the reluctant spouse simply isn’t ready to let go of the marriage. But in a recent mediation, a husband resisted moving forward for a completely different reason. He was afraid of how the divorce might affect the bond between his children.

He explained that he and his sister had been very close growing up. However, when their parents divorced during their teenage years, the two quickly drifted apart and today they are estranged. Having lived through that loss himself, he feared his own children might suffer the same fate.

In all my years of mediating, no one had ever raised this concern. It left me wondering how often a divorce shapes the bond between the children, for better or worse. As the research shows, the answer isn’t simple.

It’s also a question that rarely comes up. Most discussions about divorce center on the spouses and on each parent’s relationship with the children. The bond between siblings – whether brothers, sisters or both – is often left out of the conversation.

That bond matters long before adulthood. Through years of shared routines, rivalry and companionship, siblings help shape one another’s emotional development, sense of self and social skills such as sharing, compromising, respecting boundaries, humor and empathy, sometimes as much as or even more than parents do.

Divorce can quietly pull siblings apart or draw them closer. Which way it goes often depends on choices the adults make along the way.

Why Siblings Drift Apart

When the sibling bond frays, the loss often goes unnoticed by parents and other family members and even the siblings themselves may not acknowledge it. As one clinical social worker put it, children are “of the marriage, not in the marriage.”¹ They don’t fully know what happened, but they absorb the fallout.

A Columbia University study comparing more than 1,000 young adults from divorced and intact families suggests that parental divorce can weaken the bond between siblings.² Those whose parents had divorced reported feeling less warmth toward their siblings. Rather than fighting, they appeared to simply drift apart, often after leaving home when staying close became a choice rather than a given.

The study offers several possible explanations:

  • Putting parents first – Siblings who were never especially close may be the most vulnerable. According to the study, they are more likely to treat their relationship with each other as secondary to their relationships with their parents. As a result, they may let the sibling bond suffer to meet their parents’ needs, or what they believe those needs to be. Some may even intensify the rivalry to show loyalty to one parent.
  • Too different to get along – Divorce can teach children that irreconcilable differences can end even the closest relationship. The study suggests siblings may apply that same lesson to each other, coming to see themselves as too different and ultimately incompatible.
  • Competing for a less available parent – After divorce, if one parent is less available to see or speak with the children, the study suggests siblings may end up competing for that parent’s limited time and attention, sparking rivalry between them.
  • Unequal treatment – Earlier research reviewed in the study found that when parents treat their children differently, siblings tend to have more conflict with each other. This can involve attention, discipline or how much each child is drawn into the parents’ conflict. Divorce may make this kind of uneven treatment more likely. Even without meaning to, parents can breed resentment between siblings.

Drifting apart can affect siblings well into adulthood. Some step away from the family altogether, finding a greater sense of security in a “chosen family” of partners and close friends.¹

Why Some Siblings Grow Closer

Divorce does not always pull siblings apart. For many, it does the opposite. Several studies have found that siblings who go through their parents’ divorce together often report feeling closer as a result.³

A few factors may help explain this closeness:

  • A steady presence – With a shared history of the same conflict and upheaval, siblings often become each other’s most reliable source of support and companionship. A sibling may be the one constant and the only person who truly understands what the family has gone through.
  • Filling the gap – Parents coping with their own grief may be less emotionally available. Siblings often turn to each other for comfort, reassurance and everyday help, from homework to college applications.
  • An older sibling’s guidance – An older brother or sister may step in to explain what is happening and help care for younger siblings, which can bring them closer.

Keeping Siblings Connected

Parents and professionals can take meaningful steps to help keep sibling relationships strong and enduring before, during and after a divorce.

  • Prioritize the sibling relationship – Recognize that the bond between siblings is important in its own right. Protecting that bond should guide decisions and arrangements as the family adjusts to each stage of divorce, including afterwards.
  • Keep children out of the middle – Avoid asking children to carry messages, choose sides or take on adult concerns.
  • Maintain family traditions – Whether it’s celebrating a birthday, watching a favorite movie, playing a particular game or keeping a holiday tradition, familiar rituals give children continuity and a sense of belonging.
  • Respect each child’s relationship with each parent – Siblings may react to divorce differently. One child may want more time with a parent while another needs extra reassurance. Parents can respect these differences without letting them divide the siblings.
  • Treat children fairly – Be mindful of differences in attention and expectations that can breed resentment.
  • Be patient – Accountability, consistency and respect for each child’s pace go a long way toward healing and unity.

Remember that divorce ends the marriage, not the sibling relationship – Parents can reinforce the bond by speaking positively about the children’s relationship with one another, encouraging contact and showing that family ties remain important despite the changes divorce brings.

The Role of Mediation – Nurturing a Lifelong Bond

Litigation tends to sharpen divisions and children often feel the pressure to choose a side. Mediation offers a lower-conflict path that gives parents room to step back from the dispute and plan with each child and each sibling relationship in mind. In the mediation I described earlier, once the husband shared his concern, we were able to address it directly in the parenting plan with an emphasis on keeping the siblings connected rather than divided.

With thirteen years devoted exclusively to family mediation following an eighteen-year litigation career, I have guided more than 3,000 families toward agreements that reduce unnecessary conflict and protect the relationships that matter most, including the ones children will carry with them long after the divorce is final.

Online mediation scheduling is available. Click here to schedule.

Menu